Me: It’s time to talk about Amityville. Whatcha got? Jay: I actually watched the sequel to The Amityville Horror before I saw the first one. It’s a better movie, the sequel, but the 1978 Amityville Horror was good. The sequel was definitely scarier though. There are moments in the first one, like the scene with […]

 Me: I know we’re starting to sound like the old broken record here but… A Nightmare on Elm Street has to go to the original, right? Jay: Right. Me: Because the new Freddy sucks? Jay: Well, Jackie Earle Haley as Freddy didn’t have anywhere near the charisma of Robert Englund. The new Nancy was okay […]

 Me: Okay, let’s talk about Pet Sematary.  Jay: It was so well cast- Me: Which one are we talking about?  Jay: The 1989 one. The original. Me: Is that your choice?  Jay: Yeah, yeah. The remake was okay. I mean, it wasn’t bad. The problem is if you haven’t seen the first one the second […]

Me: Snow Beast. Okay, so I know that you’re going to pick the original and I’m not going to argue with you. I just want you to explain why. Jay: It’s all the monster. I mean there was no menace once you saw it, which happens right away in the remake. It was a man […]

 Me: Choosing the 1985 version of Day of the Dead over the 2008 remake was kind of a no-brainer, for both of us. I think the reason for that is that it’s an okay movie but a terrible remake. Jay: It was awful, wasn’t it? Especially when you consider the fact that they kept postponing […]